This is a question I get at lot: What's the difference between a novel, a novella, and a short story?
Well, according to the RWA's contest-category page:
A “Novella” is a work of fictional narrative prose in the romance genre of 20,000–40,000 words as determined by computer word count. Novella entries with word counts less than 20,000 or more than 40,000 will be disqualified.
A “Novel” is a work of fictional narrative prose in the romance genre of at least 40,000 words as determined by computer word count. Novel entries with word counts less than 40,000 will be disqualified.
And a short story would (generally) be anything under the 20,000 word count for a novella.
There are upper limits, too, typically where the next type of manuscript starts, but in general, publishers don't want to publish a book that's over 120,000 words. They will for a few reasons, namely if you have a very popular series (or are a very popular author, like Stephen King) and the publisher knows people will buy it. For instance, the longest Harry Potter book was the fifth one, the Order of the Phoenix, and it topped out at about 257,000 words. However, the final four in the series were all well over 150,000 words. The Deathly Hallows was also right around 200,000 words. If you're not J.K. Rowling, a publisher will either reject for being too lengthy, or see if you can split the manuscript into two or more, because, hey, why sell one really long one when you're not sure if readers will buy it, when you can chop it into two and have two shorter-but-successful ones.
The problem--even though it's not really a problem, per say--is that the word counts can vary per publisher. What may be classified as one type of manuscript in one place might be a different one somewhere else, or not accepted at all. For example, a publisher may make the starting word count for a novel 50,000 words. That is, anything under 50,000 words that's submitted would either 1) not be accepted or 2) classified as something different, i.e. a novella, if the publisher publishes them.
When I started out writing The Curse, I thought it was going to be somewhere in the 30,000 word range, not making it into "novel" territory according to the RWA standards, but more of a long novella. As of right now, it's not finished and already over 32,000 words. Will I make it to the magic 40,000 word count? I have no idea. If I do, great, if not, that's okay, too. I'd like to get it up there if possible, though, because I can reach a larger market that way. Plus, publishers charge more for e-books that are novel-length.
I hope that clarifies some of these common publication terms that are thrown around.
xoxo Sarah
I just got to about 49k of my WIP and I have more story to tell (my goal is around 65-70k). I was worried for awhile because I've never gotten this far in a project before I shelved it for various reasons. Writing a novella sounds like a piece of cake now.*
ReplyDelete*note = I know this is not true; in fact, I could argue a novella is just as much if not harder to write because so much needs to build up, happen and resolve in a much shorter space.
Also, I completely fail at flash fiction. 100 words is not long enough for a story!
Very true...stories are as long as they need to be, though usually we as the writer have a pretty good idea of whether it's going to be a longer story or a shorter one. Flash fiction does seem pretty hard...
DeleteSometimes I don't know why I even decide what word count I want, because I never stick to it in the end. I have three unpublished novels that hover just above 120,000 words and need some additional work. My work in progress should be between 80,000 to 90,000, but as I said, I never seem to be right in my estimates.
ReplyDeleteIn the end, I just have to know when the story is done and hope the word count doesn't become an issue.
That's a great attitude! They'll undoubtedly be cut down in editing anyway, so don't stress about it. Good luck!
DeleteBut not even any of that is "true." It's just current convention. A few decades ago, a novel needed to be at least 60-80,000 words and before that it was over 80,000 words.
ReplyDeleteThat's true! I was just going by generalities...I'm asked what the difference is quite a lot, and that's just how I explain it. :-)
DeleteYeah, that's a good way to explain it. I get that question a lot, too. I just think it's interesting how our definitions change, but, yet, so many people today insist that this current way is -the- way it's done.
Delete